A comparison of the mayor of casterbridge by thomas hardy and oedipus the king by sophocles

He rose from lower-class rural obscurity to rank as the foremost writer of the age.

A comparison of the mayor of casterbridge by thomas hardy and oedipus the king by sophocles

Below is the abstract, which will appear in the conference booklet, as the final paragraph. Preceding paragraphs give the context of debate.

Pagan heights

That could also be summed up as the difference between the political philosophy of Robert Nozick and that of John Rawls. No one could seriously claim that Smith was a strict minarchist, nevertheless there is a definite tendency for free market libertarians to talk as if Smith did have that view, and remarkably little contribution to the recent growth of interest in Smith as a social, ethical and legal philosopher Craig Smith is a rare exception,and he is not the most influential Smith scholar aroundwith many other interests of a cultural, philosophical and scientific kind.

Chomsky and Chang are certainly not stupid, far from it, so more shame on them for talking in a such a misleading way on this issue.

Smith like many free market libertarians now, just about everyone who sails under that banner as opposed to the conservative, or sometimes centrist, establishment types, who use market economics since Smith as a defence of the establishment.

Smith was not completely an outside with regard to the British establishment certainly not in the way he would have been if he had been a Chomsky-Chang type leftist, though as they are faculty at very famous universities they are a bit establishment themselvesbut he had a very critical view of the way that the state, and the conservative forces allied with it, use it to protect economic privileges.

The examples of economic privilege in Smith are very largely to do with state interference in the economy, with anti-competitive behaviour by colluding groups of merchants firmly linked with state power.

How should I write a comparative essay for English A level?

He was not a strict minarchist, advocating for example state involvement in promoting education, though within what he thought should be largely a private education economy as noted below. There are perhaps some genuine difficulties in understanding how to apply the thought of an 18th century writer to the present day, but it is not a good procedure to insist that someone who preferred less state should be interpreted as demanding more state now.


He was also rather scornful about the luxuries consumed by the rich. I can agree with some of the left Smithians that a concept of natural liberty is open to criticism, as if liberty as we know it, and desire it, could exist without any element of state design and sovereign political institutions.

However, that is still no reason to say that Smith favoured state designed distributive justice beyond whatever is necessary to support the basics of life as in the Poor Law of the time which Smith accepted though he did not argue for themin a civilised society such as public schemes to promote transport networks, preferably with tolls, as was happening in his time.

There is now a richer and growing ecology of political and social theory between Nozick and Rawls, of which left leaning commentary on Smith is an honourable part. However, for a away of thinking which is as close to Smith as is now possible, it is best to look at what has been labelled variously as Rawlsekiansim, liberaltarianism, Bleeding Heart libertarianism and Arizona libertarianism various previous posts have explored these, please use search window to find them.

That is the growing stream of thought which regards state provided public goods, beyond minarchism, and state action to maintain the living conditions of the poorest, as allowable and desirable, within an overall pattern of economic distribution which comes from the market rather than the state, and where civil society is clearly bigger than the state, and which is suspicious of attempts to always look to the state as the first solution to economic and social problems.

This has two aspects: In both cases, the cause is largely the activity of the state rather than the results of markets being left free of state legislation and public schemes. Smith sees injustice as resulting from collaboration between merchants in the same sector, but sees this as more the consequence of state intervention than of free commerce.

The great injustices that Smith mentions to the poor come from the way the Poor Law tends to tie those under suspicion that they might apply for public funds to the Parish of birth only, and the way that requirements for seven years of apprenticeship, before practising a craft, limits the chances to the poor to improve their economic situation.

English Lit Gce a Level from September DocsBay

Another source of injustice to the poor is the application of taxes on the necessities of life. Public debt leads to a forced transfer of income from the productive sectors of the economy to creditors, that is the financial sector of the economy.

The solution that Smith advocates is reducing debt, which includes reducing public expenditure, particularly on war.The Mayor of Casterbridge by Thomas Hardy: An Appreciation The Mayor of Casterbridge is one of the major and most mature novels of Hardy.

Written during an advanced stage of his novelistic career, it possesses certain qualities of plot-construction, characterization, story telling and description, that go to make it what Richard Carpenter calls "in construction and force, Hardy's finest novel.

A comparison of the mayor of casterbridge by thomas hardy and oedipus the king by sophocles

LIST OF BOOKS. for English Literature Students OCTOBER, Please mail your order to: RAMA BROTHERS INDIA PVT. LTD. Educational Publishers. Oedipus Rex by Sophocles (77, 85, 88, 00, 03, 04) Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck (01) One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich by Alexander Solzhenitsyn (05).

Aug 04,  · Oedipus at Colonus, by Sophocles Books The Hound of the Baskervilles, by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle Medea by Euripides On the Origin of Species, by Charles Darwin The Arabian Nights: Tales of Nights As You Like It, by William Shakespeare Elizabeth Bishop's poetry Genesis, from the Bible Things Fall Apart, by Chinua Achebe A Room of One's Author: Great Books KC.

Abstract. Pedagogical methods rooted and implemented in a mode of domination, reflecting, indeed, colonial mentalities, contradict the affirmation of equality and dignity projected in global literatures, including the work of Achebe.

A comparison of the mayor of casterbridge by thomas hardy and oedipus the king by sophocles

Mayor of Casterbridge, Thomas Hardy Prisons and Their Communities: Testing a New Approach - An Account of the Restorative Prison Project , Vivien Stern.

AP English: Open-ended questions for Advanced Placement English,